A pilot in one class or year group is a sensible way to start a phone policy, but only if you decide in advance what it has to show. Choose a group that tests the whole policy, count one thing before and after, run it for four to six weeks, and scale up on three clear signals rather than on a feeling.
Key takeaways
- Pick one complete year group, or one class with all its teachers. Never a pilot that depends on volunteers.
- Count how often teachers have to speak to pupils about phones for one week before the start, and again in the last week.
- Run the pilot for four to six weeks, starting at the beginning of a term, not straight after an incident.
- Settle sanctions, exceptions and the letter to parents before day one.
- Scale up only when the count drops, teachers apply the rule consistently and no unforeseen exceptions appear.
- Where rules above school level already cover lessons, pilot the method and the scope, not the principle.
What a pilot can and cannot decide
Almost every school starts with a pilot, and that is usually the right choice: the more resistance you expect, the smaller you start. But a pilot that is not set up in advance mostly produces opinions. ‘It went quite well’ is no basis for a whole-school decision, and it is no argument for a team that has doubts either.
So first be clear about what is still open. In many European countries, whether phones may be used in lessons is already settled above school level. Two worked examples:
- Netherlands. A national agreement between the government and the education sector, not a law, says that phones, tablets and smartwatches are not used in class: in secondary schools since 1 January 2024, in primary and special education since the 2024–2025 school year.[1] The cabinet aims to extend this to the whole school day from 1 January 2027; as of November 2026 that is a target still being discussed with the sector.[2]
- Flanders. Since 1 September 2025 a decree bans pupils’ use of smart devices during the school day. In the third stage of secondary education the legal ban covers lessons only, and schools may extend it in their school rules.[3]
In both cases the pilot does not decide whether there is a rule. It decides how you organise it (phones left at home, lockers, a box in the classroom or a pouch the pupil keeps) and how far you go: lessons only, or break times too. For other countries, see the overview of phone rules for schools in Europe.
Write down one sentence before you start: ‘This pilot should tell us whether …’, for example ‘… phones in a pouch at the desk cause fewer interruptions than the basket at the door’. If you cannot finish that sentence, you are not ready to start.
Choose the group deliberately, not the easiest one
The temptation is strong to start with the class of the most enthusiastic form tutor. That gives a nice result and a weak argument: everyone knows it was already going well there.
| Option | What it tests | Watch out for |
|---|---|---|
| One complete year group | The rule and its enforcement across every teacher; closest to a whole-school rollout | Every teacher in that year needs to be on board before you start |
| One class with all the teachers who teach it | The same rule in every lesson, on a small scale | Hold on to ‘all the teachers’. One class in one subject tests nothing |
| The group where it matters most | Whether the approach holds under pressure | Riskier, but if it works there, nobody can wave the result away |
| Volunteer teachers only | Motivation, not policy | Avoid: the result will not convince the rest of the team |
Tell the pilot class why they were chosen and that their feedback counts in the review. Ideas for that conversation are in how to involve pupils in your phone policy.
Measure something before you start
This is the step most often skipped, and without it you cannot prove anything afterwards. It does not have to be complicated. One question to the teachers involved, for one week, is enough:
How often did you have to speak to a pupil about a phone or other device today?
A tally mark each time, on paper or in a shared document. Repeat exactly the same count in the last week. Two figures side by side do more for support than any argument, and if the second is disappointing, you know where to adjust instead of guessing. Count earbuds and smartwatches too; they are where phone rules most often leak (see smartwatches, earbuds and hotspots).
If you want more, add at most two things: how many minutes the start of the lesson takes, and where most incidents happen (in the lesson, in the corridor, at break time). Measuring more than this is something nobody keeps up.
Also ask the pupils, briefly and anonymously, at the start and at the end. Three questions are enough: how often their own phone distracted them in lessons that week, whether they felt they missed something important, and what would make the rule fairer. Hearing both sides matters. In the Dutch government’s 2025 monitor, schools reported mainly positive effects on concentration and classroom climate, while pupils in focus groups were less convinced and staff mentioned extra enforcement work.[4] A Flemish survey published in 2026 found small effects: less phone use at school, but more after school, and no better self-reported concentration.[5] Measure what the school can influence, the lesson, and keep expectations realistic.
Four to six weeks, prepared before day one
Shorter than four weeks and you mostly measure the novelty: almost every phone policy works for the first few weeks. Longer than six weeks and the pilot becomes a status quo that nobody takes a decision about any more.
Mind the timing: start at the beginning of a term or school year, not halfway through and certainly not just after an incident. A measure that follows an incident reads as a punishment.
Settle these points before the start
- What happens when the rule is broken, and who does it. Especially in a pilot, because this is what you want to test.
- The exceptions, in advance and in writing. See phone policy and medical exceptions. Exceptions fought over in the classroom during the pilot make the later rollout harder.
- The daily routine. Where phones go at the start of the lesson, when they come out, and what happens if a pupil forgets their pouch or key.
- What you tell parents. With a pilot too, parents should hear it from the school and not from their child.
- Formal consultation. In the Netherlands the participation council (medezeggenschapsraad) must consent to the school’s phone policy.[6] Inform it before the pilot and agree when the definitive proposal will follow.
- The review date and who attends. Put it in the diary straight away.
Example wording for parents: ‘From [date], class [name] will take part in a six-week trial of our phone arrangement. During lessons, pupils keep their phone [in a closed pouch / in their locker / in the box in the classroom]. At the end of [month] we will review the trial with teachers and pupils and let you know what we decide. If your child needs their phone for medical reasons, please contact [name] before the start.’ A full template is in our example letter to parents.
A six-week schedule
- Brief the teachers, agree the exceptions, send the parent letter.
- Baseline count and pupil check.
- Start; a five-minute teacher check-in on Friday.
- Midpoint: fifteen minutes on what needs adjusting now.
- Repeat the count and the pupil check.
- Review meeting and decision.
The review: four questions and one decision
Keep it short and concrete. Four questions to the teachers involved, and the same four to a handful of pupils:
- What did you notice in the first week, and what in the last?
- Where did it go wrong: in the lesson, in the corridor, at changeover?
- What would you do differently in a wider rollout?
- What is needed to keep this going?
The last question is the most important and the most often skipped. Policy rarely fails because it was badly designed; it fails because its maintenance was never planned. See why phone policies fade after a few weeks.
Then decide on the basis of three signals, not enthusiasm: the second count is noticeably lower than the first; the teachers involved apply the arrangement in roughly the same way; and no category of exceptions has appeared that you had not foreseen.
| Outcome | Decision |
|---|---|
| All three signals present | Scale up: the next year group, or the whole school |
| Count lower, but teachers apply the rule differently | Align the routine and the response to breaches, then run a second round in the same group |
| Unforeseen exceptions appeared | Write them into the policy first, then run a second round |
| Count not lower | Look at where incidents happen (start of the lesson, corridors, devices other than the phone) before you change the method |
A second round in the same group costs six weeks; a failed whole-school rollout costs a school year and your team’s trust. Presenting the results to doubting colleagues? See handling objections in the staff meeting.
Scaling up: what one class did not test
What went smoothly in one group will not go smoothly by itself across the school. Three things come on top.
The formal route. It differs by country and region. In the Netherlands the participation council must consent (see phone policy and the participation council).[6] In Flanders the school records the ban, the consequences of a breach and the exceptions in its school rules (schoolreglement).[7] In the Fédération Wallonie-Bruxelles the school’s internal rules (règlement d’ordre intérieur) set out how the ban works, the derogations and the sanctions.[8] Elsewhere, check what your governing body or school council needs to approve.
Newcomers. Plan an introduction for new pupils and new colleagues. Anyone who arrives in March did not hear the explanation given in September.
Maintenance. Repeat the same count after the first term. It is the cheapest way to notice drift early.
The full route from pilot to whole-school rollout is in the implementation guide. If you are still choosing a method, compare the options in phone lockers or phone pouches.
Where ’t Zakkie fits in a pilot
’t Zakkie is a signal-blocking pouch that the pupil keeps. The phone goes in at the start of the lesson and the velcro closes; inside the closed pouch the phone is offline, so calls, messages and notifications do not come in. There is no app and no data, and the pouches can be reused for years, so a pilot set carries over when you scale up.
For a pilot this has two practical advantages. Because the pupil keeps the phone, the school does not take it into custody; in the Netherlands the VO-raad points out that a school that does take phones in is responsible for loss or damage.[6] And there is no hand-in queue at the door, which you can see directly in the ‘minutes at the start of the lesson’ count.
How strong the shielding is can vary by device and by position in the pouch, so test it with a few of your pupils’ phones the week before: close the pouch fully and call the phone. Five minutes now prevents surprises in week one.

More than 50,000 pouches are in use at more than 50 schools in the Netherlands and Belgium (company figures, July 2026), and we deliver across Europe. You can request a free sample to test with first.
This article gives general, practical information and is not legal advice. Rules on phones in schools differ by country and region and can change; check the official sources and your own school rules before you start a pilot.
Frequently asked questions
How long should a phone policy pilot last?
Four to six weeks. Shorter than four weeks and you mostly measure the novelty, because almost any phone rule works for the first few weeks. Longer than six weeks and the pilot quietly becomes the status quo without anyone taking a decision.
Which class should we choose for the pilot?
Choose a group that tests the whole policy: ideally one complete year group, or one class with all the teachers who teach it. Avoid a pilot that depends on volunteer teachers or on the most enthusiastic form tutor, because then you measure motivation rather than policy.
What should we measure in a phone policy pilot?
Start with one simple count: how often each teacher had to speak to a pupil about a phone or other device, for one week before the start and again in the last week. Add at most two things, such as the minutes lost at the start of a lesson and where incidents happen, plus a short anonymous check among pupils.
Do parents need to be told about a pilot?
Yes. Parents should hear about it from the school, not from their child. A short letter with the start date, what pupils do with their phone, how exceptions work and when you will review is enough.
Is a pilot still useful if phones are already banned in class in our region?
Yes. Where a national agreement or a decree already covers lessons, as in the Netherlands and Flanders, the pilot no longer decides whether there is a rule. It tests how you organise it and how far you go, for example lessons only or also break times.
When should we scale up to the whole school?
Scale up when three signals are present: the second count is clearly lower than the first, the teachers involved apply the rule in roughly the same way, and no unforeseen category of exceptions has appeared. If one is missing, adjust and run a second round in the same group first.
Can we test ’t Zakkie before ordering for a pilot?
Yes. Schools can request a free sample to try the pouch with a few of their own phones before ordering a set for the pilot group.
Sources
- Gebruik van mobiele telefoons niet toegestaan in de klas — Rijksoverheid, accessed November 2026 (Dutch)
- Kabinet presenteert strategie om kinderen online te beschermen — Rijksoverheid, 5 October 2026 (Dutch)
- Omzendbrief NO/2025/01: Verbod op slimme apparaten (smartphoneverbod) in het leerplichtonderwijs — Flemish Ministry of Education and Training (Edulex), 19 May 2025 (Dutch)
- Monitoring landelijke afspraak mobiele telefoons en andere devices in de klas – Eindrapport eenmeting (rapport 1147) — Kohnstamm Instituut / Oberon for the Dutch Ministry of Education, 2025 (Dutch)
- Amper positieve effecten smartphoneverbod scholen — VRT NWS (press, on a Ghent University survey), 25 September 2026 (Dutch)
- Q&A Richtlijn smartphones in de klas — VO-raad, 9 October 2023 (Dutch)
- Verbod op gebruik van smartphones en andere slimme apparaten — Flemish Government (vlaanderen.be), accessed November 2026 (Dutch)
- Décret relatif à l’interdiction de l’usage récréatif des téléphones portables et de tout autre équipement terminal de communications électroniques à l’école — Parliament of the Fédération Wallonie-Bruxelles, 13 March 2025 (French)
Start your pilot with a free sample
Try ’t Zakkie with a few of your pupils’ phones before you order a set for the pilot group. Shipping costs € 3,95 and is free from € 25.
Request a free sampleRequest a quote