Giving pupils a say in your phone policy works, but only if you decide in advance what is open for discussion and what is not. Keep the decision that there will be a rule off the table, let pupils shape how it works in practice, and tell them afterwards what you did with their input. Then involvement builds support instead of reopening the decision.
Key takeaways
- Write down before the conversation which questions are open and which are not, and say so out loud at the start.
- Usually not open: that there is a rule, that it goes into the school rules, and the medical and support exceptions. Usually open: how it works day to day, breaks, communication and how it will be reviewed.
- Pupils rarely argue against any rule. They ask about fairness and practice: does it apply to everyone, to teachers too, what if I need my phone, what if I forget?
- Use more than the pupil council: a short conversation in tutor time and pupils at the review give you a broader picture.
- Report back what you did with the input, including what you did not adopt and why. That step is the one most often forgotten.
Why involve pupils, and where it goes wrong
Schools that involve pupils in their phone policy usually do it for one reason: resistance. A rule imposed from above provokes more opposition than a rule pupils have had a say in. That is true, but it goes wrong as soon as the conversation drifts towards the decision itself.
Then you are left with a pupil council that expects the outcome to be open, and a leadership team that took the decision long ago. That costs more trust than not asking at all.
There is also a good reason to listen beyond avoiding resistance. Pupils often see the rule differently from staff. In the Netherlands, the government-commissioned monitor of the national agreement found schools largely positive about calm and concentration, while pupils reported less change [2]. In Flanders, researchers who studied the ban in 2026 found limited or mixed effects and argued that a ban needs accompanying measures, such as media literacy and involving pupils [6][7]. Whatever your view of those findings, they show that pupils’ experience is worth asking about.
Decide in advance what is open and what is not
This is the whole art, and it takes ten minutes of preparation. Write down which questions are genuinely open and which are not, and say so at the start of the conversation.
| Usually not open | Usually open |
|---|---|
| That there will be an arrangement on phone use during lessons | How it works in practice: on arrival or at the start of each lesson |
| That the school records the arrangement in its school rules | What applies at break time and in the corridors, if your rules leave room for it |
| The exceptions for medical reasons and for support needs | How the policy is communicated, and by whom |
| Anything that national or regional rules already settle | What the policy will be judged on at the review |
A conversation about the right-hand column is a real conversation. A conversation that starts as if everything is open and ends with what was already settled feels like a trick, and that is how it gets retold in the playground.
Say what the rules already settle
If national or regional rules already decide part of this for your school, say so at the start: that part is not the school’s to negotiate. Three examples:
- The Netherlands: under a national agreement (not a law), phones are not used in class unless needed for the lesson or for medical reasons [1].
- Flanders: a decree bans pupils’ use of smart devices from before the first lesson until the end of the last. In the final two years of mainstream full-time secondary education the legal ban applies only during lessons, and the school may extend it [4].
- Fédération Wallonie-Bruxelles: a decree bans recreational use, and each school sets the practical arrangements, exceptions and sanctions in its school rules [5].
For other countries, see the overview of phone rules for schools in Europe.
Example opening
‘The decision that phones are not used during lessons has been taken, and it will go into the school rules. Today we want your help with how it works: when phones are put away, what happens at break time, how we explain it to everyone and how we will judge after six weeks whether it works. What you say about those points will really change the plan.’
What pupils actually bring up
Schools that do this rarely hear ‘we don’t want a rule’. What comes up is about fairness and practice:
- ‘Does it apply to everyone?’ The question pupils ask most often, and the most important one. If it applies with one teacher and not with another, the rule becomes a preference within two weeks. How to get the staff on the same page is in five staff objections and what works.
- ‘Does it apply to teachers too?’ Awkward, but fair. Schools that agree something on this, even if only during lessons, gain credibility.
- ‘What if I need to sort something out?’ Work, a placement, looking after siblings, a medical appointment. Especially real for older pupils. This is where the agreement on who gives permission comes from. For health reasons, see phone policy and medical exceptions.
- ‘What happens if I forget?’ Pupils want to know whether a mistake counts the same as doing it on purpose. If you do not record that, every teacher decides for themselves.
Each of those four makes your policy better. None of them requires reversing the decision.
Three formats that work
Pupil council, before the details are fixed
The most common format. Put the problem to them, not the measure, and ask how they would tackle it. What you get is usable, and council members can later explain the outcome to their classmates.
One tutor period in the classes involved
Broader than the council, and it reaches pupils who would never join one. Ask two things: what do you notice yourself during lessons, and what would make this workable for you? Twenty minutes is enough.
Pupils at the review
The most underrated format, and the cheapest. At the review two to six weeks after the start, ask pupils the same questions as teachers. Where those answers diverge, that is where your problem lies.
| Format | When | Who you reach | What you get |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pupil council | After the decision in principle, before the details are fixed | Engaged pupils | Practical proposals and ambassadors for the outcome |
| Tutor period | Before the start, in the classes involved | Every pupil in those classes | A broad picture of what pupils notice and need |
| Review | Two to six weeks after the start | Pupils and teachers, the same questions | Where the policy works and where practice differs |
Starting with a pilot in one class? Then the tutor period and the review in that class give you most of what you need before a school-wide rollout.
What not to do
- Vote on the rule. A vote you are not going to follow is worse than no vote. Only ask for a judgement if you can also adopt it.
- Have the conversation only after the letter has gone out. Then it is not consultation but explanation, and pupils see through that immediately.
- Speak only to the pupil council and call that consultation. A council is not the school. Use it as a way in, not as a box to tick.
- Confuse talking to pupils with formal participation. Many schools have a formal body with its own rights and procedures. In the Netherlands, for example, the participation council (medezeggenschapsraad) must consent to the phone policy [3]. A conversation with pupils does not replace that route. See phone policy and the participation council.
- Leave break time vague. If breaks are open for discussion, settle them in the same round, or pupils will keep reopening the question. Options are compared in phones at break time.
What you report back
The step that makes the difference and is almost always forgotten: tell pupils what you did with their input. Also, and especially, the points you are not adopting, and why not. Two paragraphs in the newsletter or five minutes in tutor time is enough.
Pupils accept a rule they do not like considerably better than the feeling that they were asked for their opinion and nothing happened with it. That feeling is exactly where the resistance comes from that undermines a policy in week eight.
Example report-back
‘Thank you to everyone who took part in the conversations about phones. You asked whether the rule applies in every lesson: it does, and all teachers use the same steps. You asked what happens if you forget: the first time is a reminder, not a note. You asked for phones to be allowed at break time; we are not doing that this term, because we want to see how the new arrangement works first. We will ask you again at the review in six weeks.’
Keep it as specific as this. ‘We listened to your input’ without examples sounds like nothing happened.
How ’t Zakkie can fit
’t Zakkie is a signal-blocking pouch. The pupil puts the phone in it, closes the velcro and keeps the pouch. Inside the closed pouch the phone is offline, so messages, calls and notifications do not come in. How strong the shielding is can vary by device and by position in the pouch.
It touches several things pupils raise:
- ‘What if I need it?’ With permission, the phone is out of the pouch in seconds, without a walk to a locker.
- Fairness: everyone uses the same pouch in the same way, in every classroom.
- Ownership: pupils keep their own phone; the school does not collect it.
- Privacy: no app, no account and no data.

A practical idea: bring a free sample to the pupil council meeting and let members try it. ’t Zakkie is used in schools in the Netherlands and Belgium, with more than 50,000 pouches at more than 50 schools (company figures, July 2026), and is reusable for years. We deliver across Europe; shipping is € 3,95 and free from € 25.
This article is general information, not legal advice. Rules on phones in schools and on formal participation differ per country and region and can change. Check the official rules that apply to your school and your school’s own regulations.
Frequently asked questions
Should pupils get a vote on the phone policy?
Not on whether there is a rule. A vote you are not going to follow does more harm than no vote at all. Ask pupils for their judgement only on questions where you can actually adopt the answer, such as how the rule works in practice, how it is communicated and how it will be reviewed.
Which pupils should we involve?
More than the pupil council alone. Use the council as a way in, add a short conversation in tutor time in the classes involved, and ask pupils the same questions as teachers at the review two to six weeks after the start.
When is the best moment to involve pupils?
After the decision in principle that there will be a rule, but before the details are fixed and before the letter to parents goes out. A conversation after the letter is explanation, not consultation.
Does the phone rule have to apply to teachers too?
That is the school’s choice, but pupils will ask about it. Schools that agree something for staff, even if only during lessons, are more credible when they ask pupils to keep to the rule.
Is a conversation with the pupil council the same as formal participation?
No. Many schools have a formal participation body with its own rights and procedures. In the Netherlands, for example, the participation council must consent to the phone policy. A conversation with pupils is valuable, but it does not replace that route.
What if pupils propose something we cannot adopt?
Say so, and explain why, when you report back. Pupils accept a rule they do not like much better than the feeling that their input disappeared without an answer.
Sources
- Gebruik van mobiele telefoons niet toegestaan in de klas — Rijksoverheid, accessed November 2026
- Monitoring landelijke afspraak mobiele telefoons en andere devices in de klas – Eindrapport eenmeting (rapport 1147) — Kohnstamm Instituut / Oberon, for the Dutch Ministry of Education (OCW), 2025
- Q&A Richtlijn smartphones in de klas — VO-raad, 9 October 2023
- Omzendbrief NO/2025/01: Verbod op slimme apparaten (smartphoneverbod) in het leerplichtonderwijs — Flemish Ministry of Education and Training (Edulex), 19 May 2025
- Décret relatif à l’interdiction de l’usage récréatif des téléphones portables et de tout autre équipement terminal de communications électroniques à l’école — Parlement de la Fédération Wallonie-Bruxelles, 13 March 2025
- Studie smartphoneverbod: stijging van depressieve gevoelens (KU Leuven) — VRT NWS (press), 10 February 2026
- Amper positieve effecten smartphoneverbod scholen (UGent) — VRT NWS (press), 25 September 2026
Let your pupil council try it first
Order a free sample of ’t Zakkie to show pupils and staff how it works. Or request a quote for a pilot class or the whole school.
Request a free sampleRequest a quote