Most schools quickly agree that phones go away during lessons. Break time is a separate decision, because the reason changes: it is no longer about protecting teaching time but about the social life of the school. Whether you include breaks depends on what you want to achieve, what you can actually supervise and, in some countries and regions, what the rules already say.
Key takeaways
- Break time is a choice about what kind of school you want to be: the aim shifts from attention in class to contact, movement and calm.
- Including breaks gives one simple rule and fewer switching moments, but needs more support and supervision.
- Three workable variants: lessons only, lessons plus breaks for younger year groups, or the whole school day.
- In some places part of the decision is already made: the rules in Belgium cover breaks to some extent, and the Netherlands aims to include them from 2027.
- Whichever variant you choose, write down when the phone may come out, what happens after a breach, the exceptions and how parents can reach their child.
- Start with what you can uphold, review after two to six weeks, then decide on breaks.
Why break time is a separate decision
During lessons you have a clear reason for a phone rule: attention and teaching time. At break time that argument falls away. What takes its place, such as more contact between pupils, more movement and less phone stress, is real, but it is an educational aim rather than a measure to keep order in class. That difference determines how you explain the rule and how firmly you can enforce it.
There is also a practical point. Break time is when supervision is thinnest. A rule you cannot uphold there quietly undermines the rule in lessons, because pupils learn that rules are negotiable. That is the main reason to decide on breaks deliberately rather than leave the question hanging.
Arguments for and against including breaks
What argues for including breaks
- Simplicity. ‘The phone goes away when you arrive and comes out when you go home’ can be explained in one sentence. Every exception you add is something someone has to remember and enforce.
- No switching moments. If the phone may come out at break time, there are several moments a day when it has to go back in. That is exactly where the enforcement burden lies.
- The effect schools are looking for. If you want calmer corridors and more contact between pupils, a lesson rule alone will not achieve it.
What argues against it
- Support. A whole-day rule needs more explanation and meets more resistance, especially in the upper years. Resistance is the main reason phone policies fail.
- Legitimacy with older pupils. For young adults in the upper years or in vocational education, a break-time rule can feel patronising rather than like classroom order. For the Dutch vocational sector, see phone agreements in mbo.
- Supervision. If you cannot uphold the rule in the places where pupils spend their breaks, it becomes symbolic within a few weeks.
Monitoring in the Netherlands shows both sides. Most Dutch secondary schools (83.3%) report less non-educational phone use since the national agreement, but staff also mention extra enforcement work [2]. In Dutch primary schools with a phone policy, 58.7% ban phones on the whole school site [2]: for younger pupils, a whole-day rule is already common.
Three variants compared
1. Lessons only
The most common starting point and the easiest to introduce. Little resistance, quick support. The drawback: nothing changes at break time, so do not expect any effect there either.
2. Lessons for everyone, breaks too for the lower years
The rule applies to the whole school during lessons, and in the lower years during breaks as well. The reasoning: the younger the pupil, the more they benefit from a clear line and the less resistance there is. The drawback: you have to explain why it applies to one pupil and not another. Do that explicitly. Pupils accept a difference that is explained, not one they have to guess at.
3. The whole school day, for everyone
The strictest variant and the simplest rule. It works best at schools that introduce it at the start of a school year, with an explanation to pupils and parents beforehand. Do not introduce it halfway through a term: then it reads as a punishment following an incident.
| Variant | The rule in one sentence | Support needed | Enforcement load | Works best when |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lessons only | Away when the lesson starts, out when it ends. | Low | Several moments a day, spread across all teachers | You are starting out, or have older pupils |
| Lessons plus breaks for lower years | Away during lessons; younger years also during breaks. | Medium | Breaks need supervision for part of the school | You have a clear split between lower and upper years |
| Whole school day | Away when you arrive, out when you leave. | High, and early | Two moments a day, but every break needs supervision | You start at the beginning of a school year, with parents on board |
When the rules already decide part of it
Before your team spends a meeting on breaks, check what applies to your school. National or regional rules sometimes already cover breaks. The Netherlands and Belgium show how different the answers can be:
| Where | What it says about breaks | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Netherlands (national agreement, not a law) | Phones, tablets and smartwatches are not used in class; schools may decide to ban them in the whole school. The government aims to extend the agreement to the whole school day, breaks and schoolyard included, from 1 January 2027; the details are still being discussed with the sector. | [1], [3] |
| Flanders (decree) | Pupils may not use smart devices from before the first lesson until the end of the last lesson. In the third stage of full-time secondary education the ban applies only during lessons, and the school may extend it, for example to breaks. | [4], [5] |
| French-speaking Community of Belgium (decree) | Recreational use is banned on school grounds during school time, including the midday break when it is spent on site. | [6] |
| German-speaking Community of Belgium (agreement between school networks) | Private use is banned in lessons and breaks, according to press reports of the minister’s announcement. | [7] |
Even then, the school decides how: where phones are kept, what happens after a breach and which exceptions apply. For other countries, see the overview of phone rules for schools in Europe, and for Flanders the page on phone policy in Flanders.
What to record, whichever you choose
These four things need to be on paper before the rule starts:
- When the phone may come out, in terms a pupil can repeat. Not ‘when the teacher says so’ as the only rule, because then it differs from teacher to teacher.
- What happens when the rule is broken, and who does it. A rule without an agreed response will be interpreted differently by each teacher within two weeks.
- The exceptions, in advance and in writing. Think of pupils who need their device for medical reasons or as an assistive tool; see phone policy and medical exceptions.
- How parents reach their child if something happens. This is the question parents actually ask, so include the school office phone number.
Example wording for the school rules, to adapt:
- Lessons only: ‘Phones are put away at the start of every lesson and stay away until the lesson ends. During breaks you may use your phone, except in [places].’
- Whole school day: ‘Phones are put away when you arrive at school and stay away until you leave at the end of the day. This includes breaks and free periods. Parents who need to reach you call the school office on [number].’
Also decide on the edges of the day: free periods, lunch off site, and the walk between buildings. Those are the gaps pupils find first.
Making break time work in practice
A break rule stands or falls with what happens in the schoolyard, not with what is on paper. Some practical steps:
- Map where pupils are. List where pupils go during breaks and check that your supervision rota covers those places. An unsupervised corner is where phones will appear.
- Offer something to do: balls and games, an open library or a quiet room. Ask pupils what they would use.
- Involve pupils in the how, not the whether. Pupils can help shape break-time arrangements without reopening the rule itself; see involving pupils without negotiating the rule away.
Do not pick the strictest variant straight away only to roll it back later. Start with lessons, schedule a review two to six weeks in, and only then decide on breaks. At that review, ask teachers two things: how often did they have to speak to someone, and where did it happen? If the answers are mostly about corridors and break time, you already have your decision.
The full implementation route, including the staff meeting and the letter to parents, is in the implementation guide.
How ’t Zakkie can fit
’t Zakkie is a signal-blocking pouch. The pupil keeps their own phone; once it is inside the closed pouch, calls, messages and notifications no longer come in. How strong the shielding is can vary by device and by position in the pouch. The pouch closes with velcro, has no app and records no data, and can be reused for years.
It does not answer the break question for you, but it works with each variant. For lessons only, pupils close the pouch when the lesson starts and open it when it ends. For a whole-day rule, the pouch is closed on arrival and opened on leaving: no collection moment, no queue at a locker. If you later extend from lessons to breaks, only the moment of opening changes. To weigh it against lockers and boxes, see the comparison of lockers and pouches.

’t Zakkie is used in schools in the Netherlands and Belgium and delivers across Europe.
This article is general information, not legal advice. Rules on phones in schools differ by country and region and can change. Check your school’s own rules and the official sources for your country before you decide.
Frequently asked questions
Should phones be allowed at break time?
There is no single right answer. Including breaks gives a simpler rule but needs more support and supervision. Many schools start with lessons only and decide on breaks after a review.
Can a school ban phones during breaks?
In many places it can. In the Netherlands schools may extend the national agreement to the whole school, and in Belgium the rules of all three Communities already cover breaks to some extent. Check the rules that apply to your school; this is not legal advice.
How do parents reach their child if phones are away all day?
Through the school office. Put the phone number in the school rules and in the letter to parents, and agree who passes on urgent messages.
Should older pupils have different break rules?
Some schools apply the break rule only to the lower years, because older pupils may find it patronising. If you make that split, explain it explicitly.
When is the best moment to extend a rule to breaks?
At the start of a school year or term, after reviewing the lesson rule and explaining it to pupils and parents. Not straight after an incident, when it reads as a punishment.
What about free periods and lunch off site?
Decide them explicitly and write them down. The simplest option is to treat free periods like breaks. For lunch off site, decide whether the rule applies only on school grounds; the decree in the French-speaking Community of Belgium, for example, covers the midday break when it is spent on site.
Sources
- Gebruik van mobiele telefoons niet toegestaan in de klas — Rijksoverheid (Dutch government), accessed November 2026
- Monitoring landelijke afspraak mobiele telefoons en andere devices in de klas – eindrapport eenmeting — Kohnstamm Instituut / Oberon for the Dutch Ministry of Education, 2025
- Kabinet presenteert strategie om kinderen online te beschermen — Rijksoverheid, 5 October 2026
- Omzendbrief NO/2025/01: Verbod op slimme apparaten in het leerplichtonderwijs — Flemish Ministry of Education and Training, 19 May 2025
- Verbod op gebruik van smartphones en andere slimme apparaten — Flemish government, accessed November 2026
- Décret relatif à l’interdiction de l’usage récréatif des téléphones portables et de tout autre équipement terminal de communications électroniques à l’école — Parliament of the Fédération Wallonie-Bruxelles, 13 March 2025
- Einigung: Handy- und Smartwatchnutzung in DG-Schulen ab September 2025 untersagt — BRF (press), November 2024
Try it before you decide on breaks
Request a free sample for your team, or ask for a quote for one class, one year group or the whole school.
Request a free sampleRequest a quote