Schools that want to limit phone use nearly always end up choosing between the same two routes: store phones centrally in lockers, or leave them with the students, inside ’t Zakkie. Both work. They simply solve a slightly different problem, and they put the burden in a different place.
Below we compare the two on the points where things tend to go wrong in practice. We also say honestly when lockers are the better choice. We sell ’t Zakkie, so feel free to read this page critically. That is why you will find no prices from other suppliers here, but you will find the questions to ask them.
The core difference in one sentence
With a locker, the school takes the phone into its keeping. With ’t Zakkie, the student keeps the phone; it is just offline for a while. Nearly every practical and legal difference follows from that.
Nine points compared
| Point | Phone lockers | ’t Zakkie |
|---|---|---|
| Where the phone is | Central, out of the student’s reach | With the student, but offline |
| Impact on the building | Fixed installation: wall space, fitting, power for electronic locks | None; ’t Zakkie goes wherever the student goes |
| Peak times | Checking phones in and out needs supervision and staggering at the start and end of the day | No central moment; it happens in the classroom |
| Use for learning | Difficult: the phone is somewhere else in the building | Available again within seconds when the teacher wants it |
| Liability | The school takes devices into its keeping and has to deal with damage, loss and theft | The phone remains the student’s property and responsibility |
| Reachability in an emergency | Parents reach their child through the school | The device is physically there and usable again straight away |
| Growing with the school | Expanding means adding lockers | Reorder per student |
| Several sites | A separate installation at each site | The same approach at every site |
| If the rules change | The investment is fixed, even if you want to organise things differently | Can be adjusted year group by year group |
When lockers are the better choice
There are situations where a locker solution simply fits better. Be honest about that before you decide:
- You want phones completely out of students’ hands, including at break time and in corridors, and you accept the logistics that come with it.
- You already have lockers for coats and belongings with room for phones, so the extra investment stays small.
- Your building has a natural check-in and check-out point that everyone passes.
- You have a group of students for whom simply having the device remains a constant temptation, and your staff want to remove that temptation.
When ’t Zakkie fits better
- You want calm in lessons without the school having to collect devices centrally.
- Teachers sometimes want to use the phone for a learning activity.
- You want no duty of safekeeping and no discussions about damage to, or loss of, expensive devices.
- You want to start small, with one year group or a pilot, and only scale up once it works.
- You have several sites and want the same agreement everywhere.
Watch which comparison you make. A locker solution is usually a one-off investment in the building; ’t Zakkie is an amount per student. Those are two different kinds of cost. Work both out over the same period, for example five years, and include maintenance, replacement, key or code management and your team’s time.
Questions to ask every supplier
We deliberately do not quote other suppliers’ prices; they vary by situation and cannot be compared fairly without a quote. These questions do make the comparison clean:
About cost
- What is the total cost over five years, including installation, maintenance and replacement?
- What does it cost to expand if our student numbers grow?
- What costs arise from damage, loss or wear, and who bears them?
About day-to-day running
- How many minutes a day does checking phones in and out take, and who supervises it?
- What happens when a student needs their phone for a lesson?
- How does the exception work for students who need their phone for medical reasons?
About responsibility
- Does the school take the device into its keeping, and what does that mean for our liability?
- What does our insurance say about students’ devices?
- What do we need to set down in our school rules, and how do we communicate it to parents?
What neither solution does
Neither one solves the real challenge: support. A measure introduced in week one and no longer enforced by week twelve fails, whatever the technology. What makes the difference is a clear agreement, a staff team that acts consistently, and an explanation for students and parents before it starts. Your first hours are better spent on that than on choosing between two tools.
The implementation guide shows how schools approach this, with four rollout models and a review point after a few weeks.
Frequently asked questions
Can’t a student just open ’t Zakkie?
’t Zakkie can be opened; it is not a lock. The difference from aeroplane mode is that the student cannot switch off the shielding without taking the device out, and that is visible in the classroom. It works through a clear agreement, not through force.
What happens in an emergency?
The device is physically there and usable again within seconds. That is a difference from a locker at the other end of the building. Do agree beforehand who gives permission in which situation.
We already have lockers. Does ’t Zakkie still make sense?
Sometimes it does, for example when the lockers are full of coats and bags, when checking phones in and out takes too much time, or when teachers want to use the phone in certain lessons. Schools also combine the two: lockers during exam periods, ’t Zakkie for regular lessons.
What does it cost per student?
That depends on the number of students, the rollout model you choose, the period and any custom print. We work with volume discounts and put these together for each request. Request a tailored quote and you will know exactly where you stand.
Does this need to go into the school rules?
Rules on phone use, consequences of breaking them and exceptions usually belong in the school rules or code of conduct. Which body decides on them, and which framework applies, differs by country and sometimes by region. Check the procedure beforehand with your school leadership and your governing body. There is more on our page Phone rules in schools in Europe. This is general information, not legal advice.
Can we try it out first?
Yes. Many schools start with one year group or a single class. You can also request a free sample first, to hold it and test it yourself.