A phone policy rarely fails because of the pupils; it fails when part of the staff does not carry it. The same five objections come up in almost every staff meeting, and most of them are fair. Answer each one with a concrete agreement, settle enforcement and the review date in the same meeting, and you have a policy the whole team can hold.
Key takeaways
- Have the conversation with staff before the decision, not after it. Teachers who were consulted tend to enforce; teachers who were only informed often do not.
- The five usual objections: ‘I’ll end up being the police’, ‘it’s not a problem in my lessons’, ‘I use the phone in my lessons’, ‘parents will complain’ and ‘we already have too much on our plate’.
- Most objections disappear once it is clear who does what when the rule is broken, in which words, and what happens the second time.
- Educational use is part of the rule, not an exception to it. The Dutch national agreement and the Flemish ban both allow it.
- Agree in advance what happens if a colleague does not take part. Before the start it is an agreement; in week eight it is a conflict.
Why the staff meeting decides whether a policy holds
A phone rule is only as strong as the most lenient classroom. Pupils move from room to room all day, and they notice within days where the rule is enforced and where it is not. One teacher who lets it slide is enough to make the rule negotiable within two weeks.
Enforcement is also where the effort lands. In the Netherlands, the government-commissioned monitor of the national agreement on phones in class found that schools were largely positive about calm and concentration, but staff also mentioned extra enforcement work [1]. That is the worry behind most staff objections, and it deserves a real answer.
So hold the conversation before the decision, not after it. Below are the five objections that come up in almost every staff meeting, with what works against them in practice. Not to talk them away: most of them are fair.
The five objections, and what works
1. ‘I’ll end up being the police’
The most common objection, and the most justified. A teacher who has to check afresh every lesson will no longer be doing it by November. By then the energy is needed elsewhere.
What works: show that the arrangement does not depend on daily effort. Agree exactly what happens when the rule is broken and who does it. Not ‘we speak to the pupil’, but: who, in what words, and what happens the second time. As long as that is not agreed, every teacher has to make it up, and then it differs from classroom to classroom.
Example agreement: ‘First time in a lesson: the teacher says “Phone away, please”, without discussion, and carries on. Second time in the same lesson: the teacher notes it in the pupil record. Three notes in a month: the form tutor talks to the pupil and informs the parents.’ The exact steps matter less than the fact that everyone uses the same ones.
2. ‘It’s not a problem in my lessons’
Often true. For some teachers it hardly comes up, because of the subject, the group or their own approach. For them, the policy feels like a solution to someone else’s problem.
What works: turn it around. The question is not whether it comes up in their lessons, but whether pupils meet a different rule when they change classrooms. An arrangement that differs per teacher costs most for the colleagues where it does come up. That is a collegial argument, not a policy argument, and it lands better.
3. ‘I actually use the phone in my lessons’
Also fair, and exactly why many schools do not choose a total ban. In languages, media literacy and practical subjects, the device is sometimes simply a tool. National rules usually leave room for this. The Dutch agreement says phones are not used in class unless they are needed for the lesson or for medical reasons [3]. In Flanders, use that the school decides is needed for educational goals is one of the exceptions to the ban [4].
What works: record that the teacher decides when the phone may come out, and that this is part of the rule, not an exception to it. Then choose a solution where the device is available within seconds, otherwise educational use disappears in practice. That trade-off is set out in the comparison of phone lockers and phone pouches.
4. ‘Parents are going to complain’
In practice this is usually manageable, but the concern is real: teachers are the ones who get the first email.
What works: make sure the letter to parents answers one question plainly: how do I reach my child if something happens? Give a phone number, and name one contact person who is not the subject teacher. A sample letter with notes on each part is available. Show the team that letter before it goes out: anyone who knows what was sent can answer a question in the corridor.
5. ‘We already have so much on our plate’
The objection that is rarely said out loud but most often tips the balance. Every new policy feels like one more thing.
What works: count the other side too. Ask teachers to keep a tally for one week of how often they had to speak to a pupil about phone use. Teams are often surprised by the number, and it turns ‘one more thing’ into a trade-off: time you are already losing against time you invest once. Repeat the tally six weeks after the start, and you have your first review.
The five objections at a glance
| Objection | What is behind it | What to agree | What to bring to the meeting |
|---|---|---|---|
| ‘I’ll end up being the police’ | Fear of daily extra work | Fixed steps for the first and second time, and who takes over after that | A draft of those steps |
| ‘Not a problem in my lessons’ | The policy feels like someone else’s problem | One rule in every classroom | The collegial argument, not the policy one |
| ‘I use the phone in my lessons’ | Fear of losing a teaching tool | The teacher decides when phones come out | A solution where the phone is quickly available |
| ‘Parents will complain’ | Teachers get the first email | One contact person and a clear answer on reachability | The draft letter to parents |
| ‘Too much on our plate’ | Change fatigue | A one-week tally before the start, repeated after six weeks | A simple tally sheet |
Three practical questions that come next
Once the big objections are dealt with, the questions become practical. Have the answers ready, because they decide how confident teachers feel in the classroom.
- ‘What about a pupil who needs the phone for medical reasons?’ Agree that exceptions are arranged once, centrally, and that subject teachers are told who has one. Do not leave it to each teacher to judge in the moment. More in phone policy and medical exceptions.
- ‘May I take the phone away?’ That depends on the rules where you work, so check them. Two examples: in the Netherlands a school may ask a pupil to hand in a phone but may not grab it, and if the school takes a phone into custody it is responsible for loss or damage [2]. In Flanders a staff member may ask for the device but cannot take it by force, and any retention ends by the end of the school day [5]. Teachers need to know this before the first incident, not after it.
- ‘What about smartwatches and earbuds?’ If the rule only names phones, pupils will find the gap. Decide in the meeting whether watches, earbuds and tablets fall under the same rule. See where phone policies often leak.
The question you have to raise yourself
One subject rarely comes up in the meeting by itself, and it is exactly the one that hurts later: what do we do about the colleague who does not take part?
That question feels uncomfortable to ask, especially in a team that otherwise works well. But it will come up anyway, only then in week eight, when pupils already know whose lessons it is allowed in. At that point the conversation is no longer about policy but about a person. Beforehand it is an agreement; afterwards it is a conflict.
Example wording for the meeting: ‘We all apply the same steps. If you notice it is not working in your lessons, raise it with the coordinator within two weeks, so we can solve it together. If pupils tell us the rule differs per classroom, the coordinator will talk to the colleagues involved.’ Naming one coordinator makes it a matter of routine rather than a personal reproach.
How to structure the meeting
- Start with what you see, not with the measure. First ask what colleagues notice in class. Start with the solution and you get a debate about the solution.
- Present the choice, not the decision. Put two or three implementation models side by side, with their pros and cons: phones at home or in a locker, a box in the classroom, or a pouch the pupil keeps. A team that gets to choose defends the outcome.
- Make enforcement concrete in the same meeting. Otherwise it becomes the topic of the next meeting, and by then the rollout has already begun.
- Agree who is the contact for parents and colleagues. One name, known to everyone.
- Put the review in the diary straight away. Two to six weeks after the start. What is not in the diary does not happen.
Preparation checklist
- The results of the one-week tally, if you have them.
- Two or three implementation models, each with an honest list of drawbacks.
- A draft of the enforcement steps, including the exceptions.
- The draft letter to parents.
- The formal route at your school. The staff meeting shapes the policy but usually does not adopt it. In the Netherlands the policy is recorded in the school rules and the participation council (medezeggenschapsraad) must consent [2]. In Flanders the school records the ban, the consequences of breaking it and the exceptions in its school rules [5]. See phone policy and the participation council and, for other countries, phone rules for schools in Europe.
If the team remains divided, a pilot in one class or year group lets sceptical colleagues see the arrangement work before it goes school-wide. Why a policy that starts well can still slip, and what helps, is in why phone policies fade after a few weeks. The full route is in the implementation guide.
How ’t Zakkie can fit
’t Zakkie is a signal-blocking pouch. The pupil puts the phone in it, closes the velcro and keeps the pouch. Inside the closed pouch the phone is offline, so messages, calls and notifications do not come in. How strong the shielding is can vary by device and by position in the pouch.
In a staff meeting it is one of the models you can put on the table, and it speaks to several of the objections above:
- Educational use: when the teacher allows it, the phone is out of the pouch in seconds. No walk to a locker.
- Checking: a closed pouch is easy to spot, which keeps the check short.
- Custody: the pupil keeps the phone, so the school does not collect or store devices.
- Parents and privacy: no app, no account and no data. The pouch is reusable for years.

’t Zakkie is used in schools in the Netherlands and Belgium: more than 50,000 pouches at more than 50 schools (company figures, July 2026). We deliver across Europe; shipping is € 3,95 and free from € 25. A pouch does not replace the agreements in this article: it only works if the team applies the same steps.
This article is general information, not legal advice. Rules on phones in schools and on handing in devices differ per country and region and can change. Check the official rules that apply to your school and your school’s own regulations.
Frequently asked questions
Should the staff meeting decide on the phone policy?
Usually not on its own. School leadership proposes the policy and the formal adoption follows the school’s own route, for example consent of the participation council in the Netherlands or the school rules in Flanders. The staff meeting is where the team shapes how the policy works in practice: the model, the enforcement steps and the review. That is what makes teachers carry it.
What if most of the team is against a phone policy?
Find out which objection is behind it. It is usually the fear of extra work or of losing educational use, and both can be met with concrete agreements. If the team stays divided, start with a pilot in one class or year group and decide on a school-wide rollout after the review.
What do we do with a colleague who does not enforce the rule?
Agree on it before the start. Name one coordinator, ask colleagues to raise problems within two weeks, and agree that the coordinator talks to colleagues if pupils report that the rule differs per classroom. Agreed in advance, it is routine; raised in week eight, it becomes personal.
Can teachers still use phones in their lessons?
In most systems, yes. The Dutch national agreement allows phones in class when they are needed for the lesson, and in Flanders use the school decides is needed for educational goals is an exception to the ban. Record that the teacher decides when phones come out, and choose a solution where the phone is quickly available.
How do we know whether the policy is working?
Ask teachers to tally for one week before the start how often they had to speak to a pupil about phone use, and repeat the tally six weeks after the start. Plan a review two to six weeks after the start and ask pupils the same questions as teachers.
Who should parents contact with questions about the phone policy?
One named contact person who is not the subject teacher, mentioned in the letter to parents together with a phone number for urgent matters. Show the letter to the team before it goes out, so every teacher can answer a question in the corridor.
Sources
- Monitoring landelijke afspraak mobiele telefoons en andere devices in de klas – Eindrapport eenmeting (rapport 1147) — Kohnstamm Instituut / Oberon, for the Dutch Ministry of Education (OCW), 2025
- Q&A Richtlijn smartphones in de klas — VO-raad, 9 October 2023
- Gebruik van mobiele telefoons niet toegestaan in de klas — Rijksoverheid, accessed November 2026
- Omzendbrief NO/2025/01: Verbod op slimme apparaten (smartphoneverbod) in het leerplichtonderwijs — Flemish Ministry of Education and Training (Edulex), 19 May 2025
- Verbod op gebruik van smartphones en andere slimme apparaten — Flemish Government (vlaanderen.be), accessed November 2026
Put a pouch on the table at your next staff meeting
Order a free sample and let your team try ’t Zakkie before you decide. Or request a quote for a pilot class or the whole school.
Request a free sampleRequest a quote